"My first crime junkie lesson is you don't know anyone ever. I don't care how well you think you know them. I don't care if they go to church with you. I don't care if you work next to them every single day. Unless you are that person, you have no idea what goes on within four walls of home or within somebody's head." — Ashley Flowers
"The fact, again, the fact that their throats were completely slit cut off, the gas lines broken to explode the house, not just set it on fire like a normal person. And then the vehicle's wiped down, the only reason I can see for wiping down a vehicle is that there were some kind of print or evidence in there of someone who wasn't him." — Ashley Flowers
"The craziest sighting to me actually happened up north in Canada. So all these are happening kind of all over, it's not even like there is this distinct pattern through like South America. So you know not all of these can be true, but this one in Canada is a little bit nuts." — Ashley Flowers
The episode begins by recounting the dramatic explosion of the Fisher family home in Scottsdale, Arizona, on April 10, 2001. The blast, caused by a cut natural gas line, destroyed the home and tragically revealed three bodies. Initial investigations identified the victims as Robert and Mary Fisher's children, with one adult body presumed to be Mary. Robert Fisher's vehicle was missing, and he was initially considered a person of interest who might be unaware of the tragedy. As the investigation unfolded, details emerged about Robert and Mary's tumultuous marriage, characterized by frequent arguments, Robert's past back injury and subsequent career change, and rumors of infidelity.
The narrative then delves into the police's deepening suspicion of Robert Fisher as the perpetrator. Evidence gathered included the discovery of Mary's car abandoned in a remote area, meticulously cleaned with no fingerprints or fibers found except for a single print on a coffee mug belonging to Robert, and his recovered ball cap. The brutal nature of the murders—throat slittings and a gunshot to Mary's head—coupled with the elaborate house explosion intended to destroy evidence, painted a picture of a calculated act. Despite initial efforts by Mary's family to defend Robert, he was declared a suspect, and a manhunt ensued.
The episode explores various theories surrounding Robert Fisher's disappearance, including suicide in the wilderness, living as a recluse, or starting a new life elsewhere. The presence of his dog, the abandoned car's pristine condition, and the lack of conclusive evidence left investigators and the hosts questioning his fate. The report highlights the challenges faced by law enforcement, such as the limitations of searching dense forests and the unverified nature of alleged sightings across different regions. The case remains officially open, with Robert Fisher still on the FBI's most wanted list, underscoring the enduring mystery and the difficulty in obtaining definitive answers.