"The only person I know that would help him that day would be his mom. He doesn't really have many friends at all. He's a homebody. He doesn't go anywhere. He doesn't do anything. He doesn't really have any friends." — Brit
"If you have access to somewhere, you would think you could get a search warrant even though he's not there. If I have access to a friend's house and they suspected me of killing somebody, I would assume they would still get a search warrant." — Ashley Flowers
"I mean, just share with her stuff. Keep talking about her. You know, I want people to know that she's still missing. I want her bound. Keep sharing herself." — Lisa Aikens
This episode provides an update on the ongoing investigation into the disappearance of Caitlyn Aikens, featuring an in-depth conversation with her mother, Lisa. The discussion revisits key details of the case, including the initial theories and the focus on James, Caitlyn's stepfather. Lisa addresses lingering questions about James's behavior and statements, particularly his account of dropping Caitlyn off at a mall rather than the airport, a detail that appears inconsistent with Caitlyn's familiarity with the location. The conversation highlights the difficulties investigators have faced, including the inability to access James's modified phone operating system, which has hindered efforts to gather digital evidence.
Further complexities arise regarding the logistics of the day Caitlyn went missing, including James's unexplained absence from work and the peculiar discovery of Caitlyn's damaged luggage, suggesting it may have been thrown from a moving vehicle. The potential involvement of a second person in such an act is considered, with James's mother being identified as the only individual who might have assisted him. A significant point of concern is the revelation that a second property owned by James was not searched by authorities, despite his access to it. This oversight, coupled with the confiscation of various personal items from his primary residence that have never been reclaimed, adds to the family's frustration and the perceived lack of comprehensive investigation.
The episode concludes with Lisa's plea for continued public awareness and support in finding Caitlyn, emphasizing the importance of sharing her story and keeping her case active. The discussion underscores the emotional toll on the family, their enduring hope for Caitlyn's safe return, and their ongoing efforts to seek answers despite the investigative challenges and the lack of definitive progress. The sentiment is one of continued concern and a desire for resolution.