"Listen, I feel the same way. I have a very in your face personality, and I mean, I'm done, I'm all about being weird, I'm all about being rude, and this is what I was saying before, when it comes to your safety or the safety of your loved ones, you're allowed to ignore your manners." — Britt
"The one thing I will say is when this grand jury testimony happened eight years after the disappearance, they were able to find out that the night the guys said that they were tossing around this football in the auditorium, there was some kind of choir concert going on. So there actually would have been no way they would have been there." — Ashley Flowers
"I go back and forth between whether it was Chris or Rucker myself. And even under oath, none of them are saying where her body is." — Ashley Flowers
The episode recounts the disappearance of 15-year-old Kiplin Davis from Spanish Fork, Utah, in May 1995. Kiplin was last seen at school, and her parents reported her missing after she failed to return home. Initial police investigations focused on individuals Kiplin was last seen with, including a senior named Chris and another acquaintance named Rucker. The lack of concrete evidence and the limitations of forensic technology in the 1990s significantly hampered the early stages of the investigation.
As the case progressed over several years, the focus shifted to individuals who had provided statements to the police, particularly Chris, Rucker, and Tim, who claimed to have been together at the school on the day of Kiplin's disappearance. A grand jury was convened years later, leading to testimony from various individuals. This testimony revealed inconsistencies in the accounts of Chris, Rucker, and Tim, and the group was ultimately charged with perjury for lying to the grand jury.
While the charges of perjury were established, the direct evidence for Kiplin's murder remained elusive. Chris and Rucker received relatively short sentences for their perjury convictions. Tim, who provided varying accounts of the events and implicated an unnamed individual in Kiplin's death and the disposal of her body, was also charged with manslaughter. Despite plea deals and convictions, the exact circumstances of Kiplin's death and the location of her remains remain unknown, leaving her family without full closure.